Which Roof Shingle Brand Is the Best? A Guide for Homeowners

TL;DR – Which Roof Shingle Brand Is the Best?

• Best Overall: GAF Timberline HDZ® – Most bang for your buck with top-tier wind resistance and solid warranties.

• Best Quality: CertainTeed Landmark PRO – Exceptional durability, warranties, and aesthetics. Great for Pennsylvania weather.

• Best for Curb Appeal: Owens Corning Duration® – Bold color options with reliable performance.

• Best for Hail & Sustainability: Malarkey Vista® – Class 3/4 impact-rated with eco-friendly materials.

• Best Budget Options: TAMKO Heritage® and IKO Cambridge – Affordable and dependable for basic roofing needs.

Best for Pennsylvania Homes:

• Top picks: GAF, CertainTeed, and Malarkey

• Designed to withstand PA’s hot summers, freezing winters, hail, and humidity.

Need help choosing? Paragon Exterior offers free, expert roofing consultations tailored to your home and region.

When it’s time for a roof replacement, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is choosing the right shingle brand. With so many manufacturers on the market, each offering a wide range of roofing products, it can be overwhelming to know which shingles offer the best performance, value, and curb appeal.

At Paragon Exterior, we’ve installed thousands of roofs across Pennsylvania and have hands-on experience with the leading brands. In this guide, we’ll break down the top roof shingle brands and explain which options are best for durability, weather resistance, aesthetics, and warranty coverage.

Why Choosing the Right Shingle Brand Matters

Not all shingles are created equal. The brand you choose can impact:

• How long your roof lasts

• How well it resists wind, hail, and algae

• The warranty coverage you receive

• The overall appearance of your home

• Long-term maintenance and resale value

Your roof is a major investment — and choosing high-quality shingles from a trusted manufacturer ensures your home is protected for decades.

Top 6 Roofing Shingle Brands (2025)

Here’s our breakdown of the best roof shingle manufacturers based on real-world performance, contractor experience, and customer satisfaction.

1. GAF – Most Bang for Your Buck

Why we recommend it:
GAF is the most widely used shingle brand in North America, and for good reason. Their Timberline HDZ®architectural shingles offer an excellent balance between performance, warranty protection, and affordability — offering the most value for your money. GAF also offers a luxury shingle, the Camelot® II, which has a unique design which can boost curb appeal even more.

Pros:

• Excellent value at a mid-range price

• WindProven™ Limited Wind Warranty (no wind speed limit with system components)

• StrikeZone® nailing accuracy for better installation

• Wide color selection

• Strong availability and contractor support

Best for: Homeowners looking for long-lasting performance at a competitive price.

2. CertainTeed – Best Overall Shingle Brand

CertainTeed consistently ranks at the top for premium asphalt shingles. Their Landmark series is a homeowner favorite for its rich color options, double-layer construction, and great wind resistance (up to 130 mph with proper installation accessories).

Pros:

• Exceptional durability and weight

• Industry-leading warranties (up to 50 years)

• Wide range of designer shingle options

• Class A fire rating

• Impact-resistant versions available

Best for: Homeowners who want top-tier performance and are willing to invest in a longer-lasting roof.

3. Owens Corning – Best for Curb Appeal

Owens Corning’s TruDefinition® Duration® shingles are known for their vibrant color blends and built-in SureNail® Technology for superior fastening.

Pros:

• Bold color contrast and variety

• SureNail strip enhances wind resistance

• Algae resistance built-in

• Strong brand trust

Best for: Homeowners focused on visual curb appeal with good overall durability.

4. Malarkey Roofing Products – Best for Sustainability

Malarkey offers some of the most environmentally friendly and impact-resistant shingles on the market. Their shingles incorporate upcycled rubber and plastic, making them ideal for storm-prone and eco-conscious households.

Pros:

• Class 3 and Class 4 impact-rated options

• Strong resistance to hail and wind

• Made with sustainable materials

• Excellent granule adhesion for long-term wear

Best for: Homes in hail zones or customers prioritizing eco-friendly roofing options.

5. IKO – Best Value for Budget Shingles

IKO’s Cambridge architectural shingles are budget-friendly, easy to install, and widely used in both new construction and roof replacements.

Pros:

• Competitive pricing

• Classic look

• Simple to install

• 30+ year limited warranties available

Cons:

• Fewer premium options than competitors

• Some variability in quality by region

Best for: Homeowners on a budget looking for reliable performance.

6. TAMKO – Strong Budget Option with Growing Appeal

TAMKO’s Heritage® series offers a classic architectural style at an affordable price point. It’s a solid U.S.-made product gaining popularity for its value and improved warranty offerings.

Pros:

• Cost-effective

• Appealing color range

• Enhanced limited warranties on select lines

• Made in the USA

Cons:

• Fewer high-end product lines

• Less contractor availability in some regions

Best for: Homeowners needing affordable shingles from a trusted American manufacturer.

Best Roofing Shingles by Region and Climate

Shingles perform differently depending on your climate zone. Here’s a breakdown of the top-performing, affordable shingles, by region:

Pennsylvania & the Northeast

Challenges:

• Hot summers, cold snowy winters

• Spring hailstorms, freeze-thaw cycles

• High humidity in summer

Best picks:

• GAF Timberline HDZ® – Great algae resistance and wind protection

• CertainTeed Landmark PRO – Made in PA and designed for four-season durability

• Malarkey Vista® – Flexible, impact-rated, and freeze-resistant

Why: These options offer the best blend of weather resistance, durability, and energy efficiency for homes in Pennsylvania.

Southern & Gulf States

Best shingles:

• GAF Timberline HDZ®

• Owens Corning Duration STORM

• TAMKO Titan XT®

Focus: Wind uplift, UV resistance, algae protection

Pacific Northwest

Best shingles:

• CertainTeed Landmark AR

• Malarkey Highlander® NEX®

• Owens Corning Duration FLEX®

Focus: Moisture protection, algae resistance

Southwest & Desert States

Best shingles:

• GAF Timberline Cool Series®

• Malarkey Ecoasis®

• CertainTeed Solaris®

Focus: Heat reflection, thermal crack resistance

Final Thoughts: Which Roof Shingle Brand Is the Best?

When asking “Which shingle brand is best?” — the answer depends on your budget, climate, and aesthetic goals.

• Choose CertainTeed for the best overall quality

• Go with GAF for the best value

• Pick Malarkey for sustainability and hail protection

• Opt for Owens Corning for standout curb appeal

• Consider TAMKO or IKO for affordable durability

Why We Choose GAF for Our Homeowners

At Paragon Exterior, we believe every homeowner deserves a roofing system that delivers outstanding performance, long-term protection, and excellent value — without stretching the budget. That’s why we work exclusively with GAF, the #1 roofing manufacturer in North America.

GAF’s Timberline HDZ® shingles offer the most bang for your buck — combining architectural style, high-performance materials, and industry-leading warranties at a price point that makes sense for most homeowners. Whether you're protecting a starter home or upgrading your forever home, GAF shingles give you premium-level results without the premium price tag.

We also proudly offer GAF’s designer and impact-resistant shingles for those seeking enhanced durability, luxury curb appeal, or added protection from storms and hail. Every option is backed by GAF’s comprehensive warranty system and installed by our certified roofing experts for lasting peace of mind.

Royal Sovereign® 3-Tab Shingles

A Good Roof

These traditional 3-tab shingles provide reliable performance and timeless beauty at an affordable price point. They feature a Class A fire rating and a Micro Weave™ Core that resists cracking and splitting, ensuring long-term durability. Available in 13 different colors, they offer versatility to match various home styles.

• ✔Shingle: GAF Natural Shadow
• ✔Underlayment: 15lb Felt
• ✔Ridge Cap: GAF Seal-A-Ridge
• ✔Ridge Vent: GAF Snow Country
• ✔Ice & Water Shield: Tarco
• ✔Drip Edge: F5 Drip Edge

Timberline® HDZ™ Architectural Shingles

A Better Roof

As North America's best-selling shingles, Timberline® HDZ™ offers a perfect blend of beauty and performance. Designed to resemble wood shakes, they come with LayerLock™ Technology for enhanced wind resistance and a StrikeZone™ nailing area for easier installation. These shingles are available in a wide array of colors to complement any home exterior.

• ✔Shingle: GAF Timberline HDZ
• ✔Underlayment: GAF FeltBuster
• ✔Ridge Cap: GAF TimberTex
• ✔Ridge Vent: GAF Snow Country
• ✔Ice & Water Shield: WeatherWatch
• ✔Drip Edge: F5 Drip Edge
• ✔Starter Strip: GAF ProStart
• ✔Pipe Boots: Lifetime

Timberline® UHDZ™ Ultra High Definition Shingles

The Best Roof

For homeowners seeking a more pronounced dimensional look, Timberline® UHDZ™ shingles offer a thicker, ultra-dimensional wood-shake appearance. They feature a Dual Shadow Line for enhanced depth and a 30-year StainGuard Plus PRO™ Limited Warranty against blue-green algae discoloration. These premium shingles are available in several rich color blends.

• ✔Shingle: GAF Designer Grade
• ✔Underlayment: GAF Deck Armor
• ✔Ridge Cap: GAF TimberTex
• ✔Ridge Vent: GAF Snow Country
• ✔Ice & Water Shield: WeatherWatch
• ✔Drip Edge: F5 Drip Edge
• ✔Starter Strip: WeatherBlocker
• ✔Pipe Boots: Lifetime

Designer Shingles (e.g., Camelot® II)

The SmartRoof

GAF's Designer Shingles, such as the Camelot® II series, offer the ultimate in sophistication and architectural style. Mimicking the appearance of hand-cut European shingles, they provide a luxury look at an affordable price. These shingles come with advanced protection technology and are available in a selection of artisan-crafted color palettes.

• ✔Shingle: GAF Asphalt Shingle
• ✔Underlayment: GAF Deck Armor
• ✔Ridge Cap: GAF TimberTex
• ✔Ridge Vent: GAF Snow Country
• ✔Ice & Water Shield: WeatherWatch
• ✔Drip Edge: F5 Drip Edge
• ✔Starter Strip: WeatherBlocker
• ✔Pipe Boots: Lifetime

Need Help Deciding? Ask a Local Roofing Expert

At Paragon Exterior, we help Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Delaware homeowners choose the best roofing shingle for their home and budget. We only recommend shingles we’ve tested in the real world — on homes right here in the Northeast.

👉 Schedule your free roof inspection today or reach out to us at info@paragonexterior.com. Let us help you choose the perfect roof — backed by certified installation and expert local insight.

Powered by wisp